I thought we could settle this issue once and for all. In the beginning, female FiM wanted to be called “bronies” as well, despite the obvious male connection to the name and many still do. At the time, a mini war irrupted in the comments because some insisted that female fans should instead be called fillies.
Now, two articles in a row have labeled female fans as pegasisters which does make sense because of the whole bro/sis connection.
I pose this question to you, the actual female MLP fans. What do you prefer to be called? What do you think of yourself as?